Top Rated Mascaras

Take the guesswork out of choosing a mascara! You can count on these bestsellers to deliver a five-star flutter. But don’t just take our word for it—here’s what you think.
Skip to results list

Filters

Translation missing: en.content.item_count
Product Category
Product Type
Brand
Price
to
Filter by price

Filter

Product Category
Product Type
Brand
Price
to
Filter by price
  • Limitless Lash Mascara - Clean Lengthening Mascara
    Limitless Lash Mascara - Makeup - ILIA - ILIA_2023_Limitless-Lash-Mascara_Open_2000x2000_39840da6-7a6a-4d18-8b37-270c3e180cfc - The Detox Market | After Midnight
    best seller New Shades
    ILIA
    Limitless Lash Mascara - Clean Lengthening Mascara
    $40.00
  • Natural Vegan Mascara
    Lily Lolo-Natural Vegan Mascara-Makeup-5060198293573-999120-The Detox Market |
    best seller
    Lily Lolo
    Natural Vegan Mascara
    $27.00
    Unavailable

Shop skincare from brands that meet our high standards

SWEED
SWEED
Necessaire
Necessaire
Osea
Osea
Dedcool
Dedcool
True Botanicals
True Botanicals
Manucurist
Manucurist
View all brands

Shop in-store with expert advice.

We're committed to what's best for the planet, and for you.

Our Standards + Commitments